In the run-up to the 33rd Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Economic Leaders’ Meeting in Shenzhen this week, increasing attention was directed toward the anticipated interactions among the leaders of China, the United States and Russia. Some Western commentators portrayed the gathering as a potential “Yalta 2.0”, suggesting that it could become a historic meeting capable of reshaping the international order and redefining global spheres of influence. Such speculation attracted considerable attention, but it is based on assumptions that do not withstand scrutiny.
A closer examination of APEC’s purpose, the structure of the contemporary international system, and Shenzhen’s broader significance suggests that the comparison with Yalta — where the leaders of the Allied powers met toward the end of World War II — is historically inaccurate, conceptually misleading, and politically overstated.
The “Yalta 2.0” narrative reflects a tendency to view international affairs through the lens of historical big-power politics. Under such a perspective, meetings involving major powers are often viewed primarily as an opportunity for geopolitical bargaining; diplomatic engagement is interpreted as a struggle for influence, while dialogue among leading states is assumed to be always about future distribution of power. Such assumptions overlook the realities of contemporary international politics and the actual function of modern multilateral diplomacy.
Any assessment of the APEC meeting must begin with a realistic understanding of what major international conferences can achieve. The world currently confronts a range of highly complex challenges, including trade disputes, tech competition, security disputes, regional conflicts, artificial intelligence governance, and restructuring of global supply chains. These issues involve numerous actors, competing interests, and long-term strategic considerations. No single meeting can resolve them once and for all.
In this environment, the principal value of high-level engagement lies not in producing immediate breakthroughs but in maintaining communication. Dialogue provides opportunities to clarify intentions, reduce misunderstanding, manage disagreements and prevent strategic miscalculation. Particularly during periods of heightened geopolitical tension, sustained communication among major powers contributes to international stability even when differences remain.
The significance of this week’s APEC meeting should not be measured only by the number of agreements concluded or declarations issued. Its importance also lies in its capacity to preserve channels of dialogue and reduce consequential confrontations.
Once the actual function of such meetings is properly understood, the comparison with Yalta is not compelling. The Yalta Conference was convened in February 1945. Much of Europe had been devastated, existing political structures were collapsing, and large areas faced an impending power vacuum. The victorious Allied powers possessed overwhelming military leverage and could shape the political and territorial arrangements of the postwar world. The conference therefore focused on power allocation, strategic control, and the future organization of territories emerging from a global conflict.
The contemporary international environment is fundamentally different. The international system is no longer structured around a small number of major powers that can shape the global order through closed-door negotiations. Decades of globalization have created extensive economic interdependence, while international institutions, legal frameworks, regional organizations, and multilateral arrangements have become integral components of global governance. Influence is more diffuse, and any single state’s ability to impose outcomes on the broader international community is significantly constrained. More importantly, China has consistently stated its commitment to settling international disputes within the United Nations framework.
This transformation in the international environment has important consequences for how international relations are conducted. Many of the most pressing challenges facing the world today, including climate change, public health emergencies, financial stability, energy security, AI governance and digital regulation, require collective participation. Diplomacy in the 21st century increasingly focuses on managing interdependence rather than dividing spheres of influence. The notion that a contemporary conference could replicate Yalta’s political logic therefore reflects a misunderstanding of both historical context and present realities.
The Yalta analogy is particularly problematic when applied to China. Within Chinese historical memory, Yalta is not generally associated with principles of equality or inclusive international governance. Instead, it is often viewed as an example of great power politics in which decisions affecting China’s interests were made largely by external actors. For this reason, Yalta does not hold a positive place in China’s understanding of historical international order.
China has consistently emphasized sovereign equality, noninterference, and multilateral cooperation. These themes have appeared in various forms, from the Five Principles of Peaceful Coexistence to support for multilateral institutions and more recent proposals concerning global development and governance. These policies can in no way reconcile with the suggestion of reconstructing an international system based upon exclusive arrangements among a small group of major powers.
The significance of the APEC meeting taking place in Shenzhen becomes clearer when attention shifts from geopolitical speculation to the symbolism of the host city itself. Shenzhen occupies a unique place in China’s modern development. Over several decades, it evolved from a relatively small locality into one of the world’s most important hubs of innovation, technology, manufacturing and international commerce. Its transformation illustrates the broader story of China’s reform, opening-up, and integration into the global economy.
The choice of Shenzhen as the APEC meeting venue therefore highlights themes of economic development, technological innovation, connectivity, and international engagement. While considerable attention has focused on anticipated interactions among world leaders, Shenzhen itself conveys a different message. Its modern identity is closely associated with openness, entrepreneurship, experimentation, and economic transformation. These themes align more closely with APEC’s traditional emphasis on economic cooperation and regional development than with narratives centered on geopolitics.
The APEC meeting in Shenzhen is taking place in a globalized, interconnected environment where development, cooperation, and governance challenges increasingly transcend traditional geopolitical boundaries, with an emphasis on strengthening cooperation, supporting economic recovery, encouraging innovation, improving regional connectivity, and managing competition responsibly. At a time when geopolitical uncertainty continues to affect global markets and international stability, these objectives possess significant practical value. The event should therefore be understood as a platform for regional economies to maintain communication, manage differences, and explore opportunities for cooperation.
The author is a solicitor, a Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area lawyer, and a China-appointed attesting officer.
The views do not necessarily reflect those of China Daily.
