Everybody recognizes that children must be safe online. However, unlike many other jurisdictions, the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region lacks dedicated online safety legislation. Although the Law Reform Commission has examined cyber-dependent crimes, solid progress is awaited.
As things stand, online safety is managed through specific laws. They include the Crimes Ordinance, the Telecommunications Ordinance, the Control of Obscene and Indecent Articles Ordinance, and the Prevention of Child Pornography Ordinance. There is also official guidance and intervention by the Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data, whose remit includes doxing and the unauthorized disclosure of personal data intended to cause harm.
However, the SAR lacks an online safety ordinance, as seen elsewhere.
In the United Kingdom, for example, the Online Safety Act 2023 regulates user-to-user social media platforms, search engines and online pornographic sites to protect children (and adults) from illegal and harmful content. In 2017, South Africa introduced the Cybercrimes and Cybersecurity Bill, which was enacted in 2021 as the Cybercrimes Act 19 of 2020, to protect victims of “harmful digital communications”, including text messages, pictures and other electronic communications. In Canada, the Protecting Canadians from Online Crime Act was enacted in 2014. It gave the police powers to investigate cyberbullying cases, to track perpetrators, and to seize electrical equipment used for cyberbullying activity.
In New Zealand, the Harmful Digital Communications Act 2015 aims to “deter, prevent, and mitigate harm caused to individuals by digital communications”, and to “provide victims of harmful digital communications with a quick and efficient means of redress”. It seeks to curb cyberbullying which occurs through damaging electronic communications, whether by means of emails, texts or social media posts. It: a) establishes an agency to resolve victims’ complaints efficiently; b) provides online content hosts with a process for handling victims’ complaints; c) gives the courts the power to issue take-down notices and impose penalties; d) creates a new offense of sending messages and posting material online that deliberately causes serious emotional distress; and e) creates an offense of incitement to suicide even where the victim does not attempt to end his life.
As a result, businesses in New Zealand that host sites where posts are placed must know how to deal with objectionable messages. An objectionable post is defined as one which discloses sensitive personal facts about somebody, is intimidating, is grossly offensive to an individual, can be used to harass somebody, contains a false allegation, is indecent or obscene, which incites people to send a message to an individual for the purpose of causing harm, that incites an individual to commit suicide, or that unfairly denigrates an individual because of his color, race, religion, gender, or disability. If an online content host receives a complaint about a post’s content, they must notify its author and seek a response. If the author consents (or does not respond within 48 hours), the host may remove the content complained about. If, however, the author objects, the post cannot be removed, and the complainant must be notified. The complainant can then apply to a court for redress, including removal of the post, publication of a correction or apology, an order requiring an online content host to prevent access to a post, or an order requiring the host to provide the court with information about the author. In the event of noncompliance, fines will result.
In Hong Kong, the lack of parallel online protections for young people has concerned the courts. In 2018, for example, the Court of First Instance highlighted how social media and networking sites create new opportunities for serious offending against the young and noted the absence of specific regulatory obligations on platform operators (HCCC 367/2015). Justice Kevin Zervos commented: “The tragic loss of the life of this young girl may not have happened if not for the ease of access that people like the defendant have to the young and vulnerable on social mediums and social networking sites.”
Notwithstanding the offense of accessing a computer with criminal intent (s.161, Cap.200), there were, said Zervos, no clear statutory or administrative duties on platform owners. Indeed, a banned user could reemerge using new accounts. Offending facilitated by the internet was not solely a matter for law enforcement, and operators were also responsible for crime prevention, effective user warnings, robust reporting mechanisms, and cooperation with the authorities.
It must be hoped that message struck home.
If not, the latest observations (July 31) from the Court of Appeal (Justices Andrew Macrae, Zervos and Keith Yeung) will hopefully be heard. (CACC 171/2023). A 16-year-old female was raped at the home of a man who groomed her online, and the judges noted that the pattern of using online anonymity to target vulnerable users was widely recognized. It applied not only in cases of sexual offending — the judges will have welcomed the Security Bureau’s plan, announced in June, to criminalize online sexual grooming — but “also in fraud, blackmail and other serious criminal offenses” (which should include cyberbullying).
It was, the judges stressed, incumbent upon owners and operators of social media, dating applications and other platforms facilitating contact between users “to reduce the risks, especially for minors and other vulnerable users”. Just as the public were alerted to dangers in physical spaces and products for sale carried safety information, so were comparable safeguards necessary “in the online environment where young people now spend so much of their time”.
In a clarion call, the judges acknowledged that they alone could not combat the incidence of serious offenses online. The problem required coordinated action not only by legislators, courts and law enforcers but also by schools, social services, and internet service providers. If this were achieved, it would “reduce, as far as possible, the risk of further victimization of young and vulnerable users”.
In the 2026 Policy Address, the establishment of a dedicated task force to consider the use of social media by minors was announced, and it must be hoped that their online safety will feature prominently in the exercise.
Although the SAR government should be commended for its plans not only to revamp the sexual offense laws (nine of which directly concern children) but also to review the cybersecurity situation, it is far from being “job done”. Everybody in authority must work together to ensure that all aspects of child protection online are comprehensively addressed. Only then will the community’s obligations to the most vulnerable have been fully discharged.
The author is a senior counsel, an honorary consultant to the Child Protection Institute Against Child Abuse, and was previously the director of public prosecutions of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region.
The views do not necessarily reflect those of China Daily.
