Published: 14:11, December 10, 2020 | Updated: 08:37, June 5, 2023
Huawei case called key for resetting ties
By ​Rena Li in Toronto

In this Sept 23, 2020 photo, a Huawei logo is seen during the Huawei Connect Conference in Shanghai. (PHOTO / STR / AFP)

Canadian ex-officials and a serving senator said the country has a chance to reset its relationship with China now that a new US president will soon take office. Canada should also regard China as it would a neighbor, rather than a threat, they said.

I believe we still need to have abetter relationship with China.

John Baird, former Canadian foreign minister

With the victory of Democratic candidate Joe Biden in the Nov 3 US presidential election, the United States' approach to China is expected to be different. Potential policy changes might have a deep impact on Canada-China relations as well, the observers say.

One key contingency for that change would be a resolution to the extradition case of Huawei Technologies' Chief Financial Officer Meng Wanzhou, who was arrested in Vancouver in December 2018 by Canadian authorities at the request of the US.

On Tuesday, a Canadian border official testified in the British Columbia Supreme Court in Vancouver that the US FBI was "very persistent" in seeking information after Meng's arrest.

ALSO READ: China urges release of Huawei CFO Meng Wanzhou

Nicole Goodman, a division chief at the Canada Border Services Agency, or CBSA, who was in charge of agents investigating Meng the day she was detained, told the court that an Ottawa-based legal attache for the FBI reached out repeatedly asking for Meng's travel history in Canada. The attache also sought other private information after Meng was taken into custody by the Canadian federal police on a US warrant for bank fraud.

Goodman told the court she did not have the authority to share the requested information. "I would never be releasing information to the FBI at my level," she said.

Meng's lawyers have argued that US and Canadian authorities illegally coordinated during the investigation and arrest. They claim that Canadian border agents intentionally gave identifying details about Meng's electronic devices-including passcodes to Canadian police. They further allege that Canadian police shared those details with the FBI.

Meng, 48, is facing charges of bank fraud in the US for allegedly misleading HSBC Holdings about Huawei's business dealings in Iran, causing the British bank to break US sanctions. Meng and Huawei have denied the charges.

Goodman testified that she discovered the CBSA may have accidentally shared passcodes with police during a debriefing session after Meng's arrest. The CBSA has previously testified that the passcodes to Meng's electronic devices were shared with the Canadian federal police in error.

Goodman said that when the issue of information sharing came up, her fellow agent Scott Kirkland went pale and looked distressed. "I remember it vividly," she said. "I wanted to know, what's wrong here, Scott?"

Goodman learned that Kirkland had written passcodes on a piece of paper, and he did not know whether the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, or RCMP, took it at that time, she said.

She believed the passcode sharing was "100 percent accidental".

Earlier on Tuesday, RCMP Sergeant Ross Lundie, who was serving as the force's airport liaison officer when Meng was arrested, told the court that he recalled overhearing one of his RCMP colleagues discussing passcodes, potentially to Meng's devices, with a Canadian border agent.

"At that time I had no idea why there would be passwords to phones… obtained by anybody," he said.

"The arrest of Meng did not go well, especially when the G7 was going on, there might be some misunderstanding going on," John Baird, a former Canadian foreign minister, said in an online Canada-China Economic Forum on Sunday, in reference to a meeting of world leaders.

"I could never understand why Meng was arrested in Canada. … I hope we can call upon Joe Biden to drop the case," Baird said.

The relationships with China-including those covering tourism, trade and education-were very helpful for Canada, said Baird, who also said he was concerned about the amount of "China-bashing" in Canadian media and politics.

The Wall Street Journal reported last week that the US would consider dropping the extradition request and allow Meng to return to China if she admitted wrongdoing.

Guy Saint-Jacques, a former Canadian ambassador to China, said the report was "a calculated leak" of a potential triangular solution for the three nations involved.

Li Cheng, director of the John Thornton China Center at the Brookings Institution, mused in the webinar: "With Meng's case, how much of it is related to national security, and how much of it is related to the political interest of certain groups?"

In Sunday's forum, Baird said Canada needs to take a "practical approach" rather than one focused on "values and ideology".

"We can have both. If we only want to talk about our values, we cannot work with Africa and much of Asia. I believe we still need to have a better relationship with China," he said.

Baird said that most Canadians have no idea how much overseas Chinese students bring to the country economically and culturally.

Realistic approach

Li believes that "values could be universal, but no values should be superior", and he called for a more realistic approach to China.

"If you see the COVID-19 pandemic, China controlled it very well," said Li, emphasizing how people rallied around the government response to the coronavirus. "So where would the US find people to overthrow the Chinese government? This is ridiculous. We need to be more open-minded with China."

Yuen Pau Woo, a Canadian senator and former president of the Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada, said Canada needs to rethink its relationship with China and that it is one of the most important issues for Ottawa.

Canada established diplomatic relations with China 50 years ago when the late Pierre Trudeau was prime minister. Trudeau, the father of current prime minister Justin Trudeau, said at the time that he believed it was more important to have China "in the tent".

Woo, referring to what some have called an "elegant solution" from the administration of US President Donald Trump for a possible deal to resolve Meng's case, believes the solution will be a "political one".

READ MORE: Huawei case shows true colors of US, Canada

"We know how politicized the DPA (deferred prosecution agreement) is," Woo said. "There may be an opportunity with the Biden administration; the US might want to reenter the JCPOA (Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, the nuclear deal reached with Iran in 2015). If so, it will be a get-out-of-jail-free card for Meng Wanzhou," Woo said.

Woo said China should be viewed as a global neighbor of Canada's.

"Many people might be fearful of this concept. But look at where you live; there are neighbors that are different from you, and maybe sometimes you don't like to, but you have to deal with them," Woo said.

Reuters contributed to this story.