Published: 23:02, November 16, 2026
Beyond rankings: What HK’s universities must measure next
By Roy Ying

Hong Kong’s universities have much to celebrate. Five local institutions sit among the world’s top 100 in the QS World University Rankings, with the University of Hong Kong ranked 11th globally, and Hong Kong occupies five of the top 10 spots in the QS Asia University Rankings.

Yet ranking success raises a deeper question. Now Hong Kong has already established itself as Asia’s leading higher education hub, what should come next?

For much of the past three decades, the answer appeared straightforward: improve international standing. Rankings provided a useful benchmark, allowing Hong Kong’s universities to demonstrate that they could compete with global peers. In many respects, that objective has been achieved.

The challenge today is different. Rankings can show how Hong Kong’s universities compare with global peers, but they cannot show whether the universities are creating the outcomes the city actually needs. The question is no longer whether Hong Kong universities can compete internationally. The question is whether they are producing the outcomes that matter most to Hong Kong’s future.

That question has become increasingly urgent with the development of the Northern Metropolis. The government’s planned university town across three sites in San Tin, Hung Shui Kiu and Ta Kwu Ling is not simply a campus expansion project. It is a major public investment, one that seeks to integrate higher education with innovation, industry and talent cultivation. When the city commits resources on that scale, it is fair to ask what the universities are expected to deliver in return. Whether one agrees with every aspect of the plan or not, the Northern Metropolis changes the conversation. It moves the question from international comparison to long-term contribution.

Around the world, leading universities measure themselves according to the outcomes they seek to create. ETH Zurich publishes annual technology transfer figures — invention disclosures, patents, spinoffs — alongside its academic output. Harvard and Oxford have produced generations of political leaders, policymakers and intellectuals. The National University of Singapore reports patents, spinoffs and venture funding as part of its research output, aligned with national development. These institutions differ in their priorities, but they share one characteristic: They know what success looks like.

Hong Kong’s universities, by contrast, are caught between multiple objectives. Research excellence, global reputation and economic impact all matter. Yet there is less clarity about which outcomes should define success in the city’s next stage of development.

The Northern Metropolis offers an opportunity to answer that question.

If leadership development matters, is Hong Kong systematically tracking graduates who go on to lead major corporations, public institutions or international organizations?

If innovation matters, are successful spinoffs, patents, industry partnerships and technology commercialization measured with the same rigor as citations?

If retaining talent matters, is it recorded how many graduates choose to build their careers in Hong Kong after completing their studies?

And if the Northern Metropolis matters, is anyone evaluating whether universities are producing the skills, research and entrepreneurial activity its advanced manufacturing, life sciences and artificial intelligence clusters require?

These questions receive less attention than annual ranking movements, despite being more consequential for the city’s future.

As a Hong Kong resident, I take genuine pride in seeing local universities attract world-renowned scholars and Nobel laureates. Such achievements strengthen the city’s academic reputation. Yet attracting distinguished researchers and producing the next generation of transformative innovators are not necessarily the same thing.

The late Sir Charles Kuen Kao offers a useful example. Hong Kong rightly celebrates his contributions to fiber-optic communications, but his pioneering research was conducted in the United Kingdom. The more important question is whether Hong Kong is building the conditions for future innovators of similar significance to emerge from within our own universities. Commemorating his legacy is different from building a system capable of reproducing it. If that is an outcome Hong Kong values, it should become part of how success is defined and measured.

The next stage of university excellence cannot simply be about climbing further up existing rankings. It must involve a broader public conversation about purpose.

These are the questions Hong Kong should now be asking itself. How can universities contribute both to Hong Kong’s development and to the broader needs of the nation? What kind of contribution should they make to Hong Kong’s future prosperity? How should they support economic transformation and technological innovation?

Different answers will produce different metrics. That is as it should be. It would be surprising if Hong Kong’s priorities were identical to those of every other higher education system in the world.

International rankings should continue to matter. They remain valuable indicators of academic competitiveness and global reputation. But they should not be mistaken for a complete definition of success.

Having demonstrated that its universities can compete on the world’s stage, Hong Kong now faces a more important task: deciding what success means on its own terms.

Rankings helped Hong Kong prove its excellence. The next chapter should focus not on whether our universities can climb a few places higher, but on whether each can define a distinctive purpose and make a distinctive contribution to society. Institutions that prioritize entrepreneurship, technological innovation, public leadership or professional practice will naturally cultivate different cultures, strengths and graduates. Hong Kong’s universities should be able to explain not only where they sit in a league table, but also what distinctive contribution they make to society and what kind of graduates they exist to develop.

 

The author is a senior lecturer at the Hang Seng University of Hong Kong and co-chair of the Advocacy and Policy Research Committee, the Hong Kong Institute of Human Resource Management.

The views do not necessarily reflect those of China Daily.