Published: 11:41, April 17, 2025
Carney faces off with chief rival during first Canada debate
By Xinhua
Canada Liberal Leader Mark Carney makes an announcement during a federal election campaign stop at Intelligent City in Delta, British Columbia, Canada, April 8, 2025. (THE CANADIAN PRESS VIA AP)

OTTAWA - Prime Minister Mark Carney faced off with his chief rival for the first time during Canada's election campaign on Wednesday, in a French-language debate that could help determine who wins the April 28 vote and then deals with US tariffs.

Polls show the ruling Liberals, who have been in power for 9-1/2 years, ahead of the Conservatives led by Pierre Poilievre.

Carney has admitted his French is imperfect. Jean-Marc Leger, head of Quebec-based polling firm Leger, said Carney exceeded expectations in a debate that produced no obvious gaffes.

Carney, who served as head of the central banks of both Canada and England, says his experience in dealing with crises makes him the best choice to negotiate with US President Donald Trump, who has said he wants to annex Canada.

Carney briefly served as economic adviser to former Liberal Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who Poilievre blames for rising prices and a chronic housing shortage.

"You are just like Justin Trudeau ... we need change and you, Mr. Carney, are not change," Poilievre told Carney.

"Mr. Poilievre is not Mr. Trudeau and neither am I. This election (is about) the question of who will succeed, and who will face up to Trump," Carney retorted.

The clash was the first between the two men since Carney was elected Liberal leader in March.

Conservative commentator Dimitri Soudas gave Carney and Poilievre high grades, but said the Conservative leader may have missed a chance to attract undecided voters.

Under Carney, Canada has retaliated with counter-tariffs against the US and Poilievre has said he would take a similar approach.

Poilievre accuses the Liberals of having weakened the country's economy by blocking the development of natural resources such as oil and wanting to increase taxes.

ALSO READ: Canadian academics advised against non-essential travel to US

Poilievre said Carney was repeating the same promises Trudeau had made during his time in power and accused him of driving up house prices. Carney noted he had been governor of the Bank of England for much of the period in question.

"You had a horrible record in England," said Poilievre, noting house prices jumped when Carney was in London.

The high cost of living and the housing crisis dominated domestic politics until this year, when Trump threatened annexation and imposed tariffs, and Trudeau announced he was stepping down.

The debate took place in Montreal, the largest city in predominantly French-speaking Quebec. The province has 78 of the 343 seats in the House of Commons and is usually regarded as one of the keys to victory.

Quebec has a history of political volatility, which is in part linked to the fortunes of the separatist Bloc Québécois, a party that wants independence for the province.

Organizers moved the debate forward by two hours to avoid clashing with a critical Montreal Canadiens game.

The Bloc won 54 seats in the 2004 election, slumped to just four in 2011 and rebounded to 32 in 2019 and 2021.

Polls show some Bloc voters intend to vote Liberal because they see Carney as the best choice of prime minister to deal with Trump.

Leaders of the four main parties will hold an English-language debate on Thursday. The other parties taking part are the Bloc and the left-leaning New Democratic Party.